Looking at the last simulations, there were just two changes:
Netherlands took the last League A spot, although Wales were favorites to clinch it.
Same thing happened in League B, with Czech Republic pipping Hungary.
League A
Pot 1: Germany, Portugal, Belgium, Spain
Pot 2: France, England, Switzerland, Italy
Pot 3: Poland, Iceland, Croatia, Netherlands
League B
Pot 1: Austria, Wales, Russia, Slovakia
Pot 2: Sweden, Ukraine, Republic of Ireland, Bosnia and Herzegovina
Pot 3: Northern Ireland, Denmark, Czech Republic, Turkey
League C
Pot 1: Hungary, Romania, Scotland, Slovenia
Pot 2: Greece, Serbia, Albania, Norway
Pot 3: Montenegro, Israel, Bulgaria, Finland
Pot 4: Cyprus, Estonia, Lithuania
League D
Pot 1: Azerbaijan, FYR Macedonia, Belarus, Georgia
Pot 2: Armenia, Latvia, Faroe Islands, Luxembourg
Pot 3: Kazakhstan, Moldova, Liechtenstein, Malta
Pot 4: Andorra, Kosovo, San Marino, Gibraltar
1 Germany 40747 2 Portugal 38655 3 Belgium 38123 4 Spain 37311 5 France 36617 6 England 36231 7 Switzerland 34986 8 Italy 34426 9 Poland 32982 10 Iceland 31155 11 Croatia 31139 12 Netherlands 29866 ------------------------------- 13 Austria 29418 14 Wales 29269 15 Russia 29258 16 Slovakia 28555 17 Sweden 28487 18 Ukraine 28286 19 Republic of Ireland 28249 20 Bosnia and Herzegovina 28200 21 Northern Ireland 27127 22 Denmark 27052 23 Czech Republic 27028 24 Turkey 26538 ------------------------------- 25 Hungary 26486 26 Romania 26057 27 Scotland 25662 28 Slovenia 25148 29 Greece 24931 30 Serbia 24847 31 Albania 24430 32 Norway 24208 33 Montenegro 23912 34 Israel 22792 35 Bulgaria 22091 36 Finland 20501 37 Cyprus 19491 38 Estonia 19441 39 Lithuania 18101 ------------------------------- 40 Azerbaijan 17761 41 FYR Macedonia 17071 42 Belarus 16868 43 Georgia 16523 44 Armenia 15846 45 Latvia 15821 46 Faroe Islands 15490 47 Luxembourg 14231 48 Kazakhstan 13431 49 Moldova 13130 50 Liechtenstein 10950 51 Malta 10870 52 Andorra 10240 53 Kosovo 9950 54 San Marino 8190 55 Gibraltar 7550
I made a simulation for the Nations League:
ReplyDeletehttp://simtheworld.blogspot.co.il/2017/10/uefa-nations-league-201819-simulations.html?m=1
Will post the Euro 2020 qualifying tomorrow...
Can you make simulation for other groups, not just A.
DeleteHere they are:
Deletehttp://simtheworld.blogspot.com/2017/10/uefa-nations-league-2018-19-all-leagues-simulations.html
BTW, didn't have time to post my simulations for Euro 2020, but will hopefully do it today.
DeleteI couldn't understand why the draw for the 2020 Euro will take place only in December of 2018, then I read that the Nations League will be used to seed the 2020 Euro draw (positions in NL, not coefficients). Is this the way seeding in Europe will work from now on?
ReplyDeleteAlso, the Final Four takes place during dates set for Euro 2020 qualifying matches. Considering the crowded calendar, when are the postponed matches set to be played?
Two things:
Delete1) The EURO qualifiers are as normal but they start in March 2019. UEFA has stated that any team in the final four of the Nations League will be known at the time of the draw (december 2, 2018) and will hence be in a qualifying group of only 5 teams. This means that the double matchday in June can be used for the final four.
2) The nations league will not determine seeding. The qualifying draw seeding will be the 2017 National team Coefficient which was released a few days ago. The 2020 final tournament draw will be based on the November 2019 National Team Coefficient (the Nations League will indirectly affect this coefficient due to points gained from matches won etc.) HOWEVER, the nations league performance will directly affect the playoff spots for the final tournament, because teams will get into the playoffs for being good in the Nations League (and if they havent already qualified to EURO 2020). There is no playoff spot for best 3rd place team etc. from the regular qualifying process.
Hope that clears things up :)
Nations League position WILL determine the seedings for the Euro 2020 qualifiers. It's been confirmed by UEFA. This means that bottom two teams from League A will be in Pot 2.
DeleteHowever, the seedings for the Euro 2020 final tournament will probably be determined by the UEFA national team coefficient rankings with the following weightings:
40% Euro 2020 qualifiers
40% WC 2014 qualifiers and final tournament
20% Euro 2016 qualifiers and final tournament.
Nations League results do not impact the national team coefficients.
WC 2018, not 2014. That was a typo.
DeleteNogomet, do you have any source for your last two claims ?
DeleteNo, this is my assumption because I think this is the only solution that makes sense. Plus, this website thinks so too: http://www.footballseeding.com/national-ranking-uefa/ranking-2019/
DeleteI find odd that the teams that have qualified for the Final Four would be placed in the groups of five because it goes against UEFA's policy in the last qualifying tournaments. They have been placing the big, profitable teams (Germany, England, Spain, Italy, France) in the groups of six to have more revenues.
DeletePlaying in the final four will certainly give more revenue than playing two games vs Gibraltar or San Marino.
Delete1) OK
ReplyDelete2): it is clearly stated in this media briefing pdf that the draw of the UEFA Euro 2020 qualification is seeded based on UNL results.
There will be an overall UNL-ranking based on performance in the UNL groups. Tie-breakers for this ranking will be:
- position in group
- points
- goal difference
- goals scored
- away goals scored
- wins
- away wins
- fair play
- coefficient ranking
You can see that the NT coefficient ranking is still mentioned but only as last deciding tool.
The document where it is clearly stated is not the link above, but the regulations for the UNL 2018/2019. See art 18.03.
ReplyDeleteI read an article saying that the UNL up to World Cups will also provide 4 play-off places, so that only 9 teams (If UEFA has 13 places to allocate) will qualify through the regular qualification tournament. Has this even been decided yet or is this just speculations at this time?
ReplyDeleteJust speculation. I haven't seen any official confirmed information about the role of UNL in World Cup 2022 qualifying.
DeleteIt was debated that with 55 teams (Russia will return to qualifiers after World Cup) UEFA cannot make 9 group with 6 teams because 1 team still remains so one of possible scenarios for 2022 World Cup qualifying is: 11 groups of 5 teams each with only winners taking World Cup spots and runners-up eliminated. Then 2 places would be contested by League A teams and League B teams (or both by League A teams).
DeleteBut the most interesting question for this moment is: will UEFA change the seeding system for qualifiers? It seems to be clear that results from last cycles (Euro 2016 with preliminaries + freshly finished WC 2018 preliminaries and Russian final tournament) will be totally discarded for Euro 2020 seeding. I am not sure if this is a good idea.
Well, not completely discarded, as they do determine the leagues, which determine the range of possible pots. WC 2018 PO + final tournament is discarded indeed.
DeleteI can't even imagine UEFA giving WC spots to League B, League C, or League D teams. I expect that the next Nations League won't count at all for WC qualification.
DeleteI think UEFA will have ten groups of 5 and 6 with the winners qualifying for the World Cup. Of the second place finishers, only the top six would go to the play-offs.
Personally I'd rather see seven groups of seven or eight teams with no play-offs. The top two teams of each group make it to the WC with the exception of the worst second place finisher.
Here are the the simulations for all leagues:
ReplyDeletehttp://simtheworld.blogspot.com/2017/10/uefa-nations-league-2018-19-all-leagues-simulations.html
And finally, here are the simulations for Euro 2020 Qualifing:
ReplyDeletehttp://simtheworld.blogspot.com/2017/10/uefa-euro-2020-qualifying-simulations.html
I'll make a comparison with alternative systems on the coming days.
I don't understand some unclear things i n the UNL, the 4 spots for euro 2020 from play off, I mean that with 1 spot for league D u force many lower teams to lose to stay in league D...for example lithuania the last team of league C hasno chance to qualify instead of macedonia that is first in the league D, is it possible??? in addition what happen if only 1 or 2 teams from league A go to play off(the others are qualified from regular qualifiers)??? what teams complete the group...the first 2 of league B???in this way play with 2 teams stronger and have lesschance to qualify...who can explain these things??
ReplyDeleteHere is an explanation:
Deletehttp://www.footballseeding.com/international-tournaments/euro-2020/
As for your question
But what if there will be less than 4 non-qualified teams in given League? There are two possible replacing methods:
1) If this League has at least 1 non-qualified group winner, than the free spots in this League will be filled by best non-qualified teams from LOWER League.
2) If this League doesn't have any non-qualified group winner, than the free spots in this League will be filled by overall best non-qualified teams - from ANY League. The reason for two methods of the replacing is rule that group winners can't play in the play-offs against teams from higher Leagues.
Read more: http://www.footballseeding.com/international-tournaments/euro-2020/
So if only 1 or 2 teams in League A available for League A play-off then rest 2-3 teams will be taken from League B or C among the non-group-winners (because group winners cannot play in play-off against the teams from higher leagues).
DeleteMore interesting situation is when there are less then 4 teams available for play-off in League B and more than 4 in League A.
Then fate of the team from League A that not qualified to League A play-off will depend if there are any group winners in League B playoff. If no then teams from League A can be added to League B play-off. But if any then these League A teams have no chance to participate in play-offs.
Hardly realistic situation but theoretically probable.
This comment has been removed by the author.
Deleteok thank u, but it's incredible that teams like georgia,macedonia and azerbaijan in november 2018 after the end of first round already will know that play in march 2020 for a spot in euro 2020 while teams like norway,slovenia or austria maybe won't have chance to qualify or they play with stronger teams in play off...I don't understand this choice of UEFA, it was better a play off with every team from all the leagues(A vs D and B vs C) playing in neutral ground.
ReplyDeleteHi Ed,
ReplyDeleteCan you clarify the seedings process for the proper Euro 2020 qualifiers.
In respect to Rep Ireland, in Nations League Group B, which consists of teams ranked 13 to 24 by UEFA, these rankings are made up of the last 3 qualifying campigns (WC14, Eu16 & WC18).
Q.1 So is the Rep Ireland guaranteed to be seeded at best 13 and at worst 24 in the Euro 2020 qualifying seedings?
Q.2 Are the Nations League results added to the existing points totals (from last 3 qualifying campaigns) to form the seedings for Euro 2020 qualifying draw.
Q.3 could a team in Nations League B (consisting of teams ranked 13 to 24) win all their games and do enough to be one of the ten No.1 seeds for Euro 2020 qualifying draw? Or are they limited to being seeded 13 to 24?
Wait Ger,
ReplyDeletethe Euro 2020 Qualification is seeded based on the overall UEFA Nations League rankings. The order of teams in this ranking is established as follows (according to the UNL 2018/2019 regulations art. 18):
- 12 League A teams according to their league ranking (with positions 1 to 4 resulting from the Final Four in June 2019);
- 12 League B teams according to their league ranking;
- 15 League C teams according to their league ranking;
- 16 League D teams according to their league ranking;
And each League ranking is ordered by:
a. position in the group;
b. higher number of points;
c. superior goal difference;
d. higher number of goals scored;
e. higher number of away goals scored;
f. higher number of wins;
g. higher number of away wins;
h. lower disciplinary points total based only on yellow and red cards received (red card = 3 points, yellow card = 1 point, expulsion for two yellow cards in one match = 3 points);
i. position in the UEFA national team coefficient rankings.
Except for League C where:
- the results against fourth-placed teams are not taken into account for the purposes of comparing teams placed first, second and third in their respective groups;
- all results are taken into account for the purposes of comparing teams placed fourth in their respective groups.
So just the results of the UNL 2018/2019 will determine the seeding for the Euro 2020 qualifiers. For the Republic of Ireland this means they will always be seeded between 13th and 24th spot for the EURO 2020 qualifiers.
As you can see, the existing UEFA national team coefficient rankings is still maintained but lowest in the pecking order of tie-breakers only, so just to determine complete stale-mates between teams. For the UNL 2018/2019 the existing UEFA NT ranking is used, established in the usual way. But it is yet unclear:
- if the UNL matches will be incorporated in this ranking in future ?
- if possibly a weighting for types of matches will be applied then ?
- what other purposes this NT ranking will serve in future (f.i. the seeding of the EURO 2020 finals draw) ?